The subsequent dissolution of the Soviet Union gives these
arguments an additional historical significance. The bureaucracy that
proclaimed Trotskyism politically bankrupt ultimately presided over the
destruction of the USSR and the restoration of capitalism. Basmanov’s work
should therefore be read today primarily as a document of Stalinist political
ideology, revealing how the Soviet apparatus sought to answer an opposition
whose analysis of bureaucracy, nationalism and the danger of capitalist restoration
raised questions that official Soviet historiography could never satisfactorily
resolve.
Who was Mikhail Basmanov?
Biographical information on Basmanov is surprisingly scarce
in readily available sources. We can establish with greater certainty his
political and literary role in the Soviet ideological apparatus. He was a
specialist writer on Trotskyism, and his best-known work, Contemporary
Trotskyism: Its Anti-Revolutionary Nature, was published in English by Moscow’s
Progress Publishers in 1972 under the auspices of the CPSU Central Committee's
Institute of Marxism-Leninism.
The circumstances of the book’s production are particularly
revealing. The publisher of the new edition describes Basmanov as a
“professional in the genre” of Soviet anti-Trotskyist literature and connects
the book with a 1971 directive by CPSU Central Committee Secretary Ponomarev
calling for an ideological offensive against Trotskyism. Contemporary
Trotskyism therefore cannot be approached simply as an academic historian's
independent scholarship. Its original title page explicitly identifies the
Institute of Marxism-Leninism of the CC CPSU, while its chapters attack
Trotsky, permanent revolution, the Fourth International and contemporary
Trotskyist organisations from the standpoint of official Soviet ideology.
David North and the Stalinist falsification of Trotskyism
Basmanov’s Contemporary Trotskyism becomes clearer when
placed within the broader tradition of historical falsification examined by
David North. North’s defence of Trotsky has repeatedly insisted that attacks
upon Trotsky cannot be separated from the political struggle over the
historical meaning of the October Revolution, the rise of Stalinism and the
fate of the Soviet Union. His In Defence of Leon Trotsky, for example,
challenges what he regards as the transmission of Stalinist distortions into
contemporary historical writing. The WSWS presentation of the Russian edition
described the book as a refutation of attacks by British historians upon
Trotsky’s political and intellectual legacy and explicitly connected these
controversies with the earlier Stalinist falsification of Soviet history. [wsws.org]
This provides an important framework within which to read
Basmanov. The essential issue is not whether we can dismiss every factual
assertion in Contemporary Trotskyism because its author wrote within the
official Soviet ideological apparatus. The more profound question concerns the
political method by which Trotskyism is defined. Rather than beginning with
Trotsky's programme and historical writings and examining their relationship to
the major experiences of the twentieth-century working class, the Stalinist
polemical tradition began by identifying the Soviet bureaucracy with socialism.
Opposition to that bureaucracy could consequently be represented as opposition
to the Soviet Union and, ultimately, as counter-revolution.
North’s writings approach the question from the opposite
standpoint. In a 2024 speech commemorating Trotsky’s exile on Büyükada, he
situated Trotsky’s historical importance particularly in relation to the defeat
of the German working class, the rise of Nazism and Stalinist betrayals in
Germany, France and Spain. He argued that understanding these historical
defeats remains necessary to confronting contemporary political problems. This
emphasis on historical experience exposes the fundamental weakness of
Basmanov’s method. Trotskyism must be judged not by the denunciatory vocabulary
of official Soviet ideology but by examining the policies for which Trotsky and
his opponents actually fought. [wsws.org]
The contrast became still more important after 1991. The
bureaucracy that had declared Trotskyism historically bankrupt presided over
the Soviet Union's final crisis and dissolution. The WSWS account of the
Russian publication of In Defence of Leon Trotsky explicitly links the Soviet
Union's fate to the historical struggle between Trotsky, the Left Opposition,
and Stalinism, arguing that contemporary political questions in Russia cannot
be understood apart from that history. Whatever judgement one ultimately
reaches about North’s political conclusions, this is a question that any
retrospective defence of the official Soviet attack on Trotskyism must answer. [wsws.org]
In this context, republishing Mikhail Basmanov’s
Contemporary Trotskyism: Its Anti-Revolutionary Nature offers more than
antiquarian interest. The Soviet attack on Trotsky did not disappear with the
state apparatus that produced it. Stalinist distortions of Trotsky and the
Russian Revolution continued to find expression long after the USSR's
dissolution. Basmanov’s book, now republished with a critical introduction by
Dmitry Chasovennikov, deserves attention because it preserves, in unusually
concentrated form, the political methods the Soviet bureaucracy used to
discredit Trotsky, the Left Opposition, and the Fourth International.
The book's historical provenance is unmistakable.
Contemporary Trotskyism appeared in English from Progress Publishers in Moscow
in 1972 and carried on its title page the attribution “Institute of
Marxism-Leninism of the CC CPSU”. Its chapters announce the political character
of the work before the argument has properly begun: “How the Trotskyites
Permanently Fought Against the Revolution”, “A Scornful Attitude to the
Peasantry”, “The Ideological Collapse of Trotskyism”, and “How the ‘Fourth
International’ Was Hammered Together and What Came of It”.
This was not history written from an academic distance. It
was political propaganda produced by an official institution of the Communist
Party of the Soviet Union against the revolutionary tendency whose leading
representatives had been persecuted and physically annihilated by the Stalinist
bureaucracy during the preceding decades. The circumstances surrounding its
production underline this character. The publisher of the new edition states
that, in Kommunist no. 18 of 1971, Boris Ponomarev, secretary of the CPSU
Central Committee, called for exposing Trotskyism’s supposed connections with
anti-communism and right- and left-wing opportunism. It describes Basmanov’s
volume as executing that political directive “at book length”. Contemporary
Trotskyism's interest, therefore, lies far less in what it can tell readers
about Trotskyism than in what it reveals about Stalinism.
Why 1972?
The date of publication is essential to understanding the
book. Basmanov was writing in the aftermath of a period of enormous
international political upheaval. The revolutionary crisis in France in
May-June 1968, the struggles surrounding the Prague Spring, mass international
opposition to the Vietnam War, and the political radicalisation of a new
generation transformed the political atmosphere in Europe and beyond.
Even Basmanov could not simply ignore this process. The
opening of his book describes the period as one of profound revolutionary
change, specifically citing intensifying class struggle in advanced capitalist
countries and the emergence of students and parts of the intelligentsia as
active political forces. The new publisher draws attention to an even more
revealing feature of the original. Basmanov himself acknowledged that, after
supposedly being defeated during the 1920s and 1930s, Trotskyist movements
began to revive from the 1950s onward. The publisher argues that the intensity
of the Soviet polemic reflected the growth of the Fourth International and
other radical tendencies among workers and students after 1968.
This contradiction runs through the whole enterprise. The
Soviet bureaucracy insisted that Trotskyism was politically bankrupt,
historically discredited and without a significant social base. Yet it
continued to devote considerable ideological resources to combating it. The
very existence of Contemporary Trotskyism is therefore evidence that the
bureaucracy did not regard Trotsky’s political heritage with the indifference
appropriate to a genuinely dead tendency.
Basmanov’s subsequent work makes the anxiety still clearer.
In 1973 the Novosti Press Agency in Moscow published his Where Are Trotskyites
Leading the Youth?, an English-language pamphlet of roughly 100 pages dealing
explicitly with Trotskyism, political activity and youth. The title itself
tells us something important. The bureaucracy was no longer merely conducting
retrospective arguments about disputes from the 1920s. It was concerned with
the influence of Trotskyist ideas upon a contemporary younger generation.
The method of the Stalinist school of falsification
The organisational structure of Contemporary Trotskyism
displays the characteristic method of official Soviet anti-Trotskyism.
Permanent revolution becomes an alleged rejection of the revolutionary
capacities of the peasantry. Opposition to the Stalinist programme of socialism
in one country becomes disbelief in socialism itself. The Soviet bureaucracy
identifies opposition to its diplomatic manoeuvres and political betrayals as
hostility to the Soviet Union.
The table of contents demonstrates the procedure
particularly clearly. Basmanov moves from supposed Trotskyist hostility to the
peasantry to the “rejection” of socialism in one country, the alleged
ideological collapse of Trotskyism and finally the claim that contemporary
Trotskyism was undermining the anti-imperialist and national liberation
movements.
The method is significant. Political disagreements are not
analysed according to their actual historical content. Instead, opposition to
the policies of the Soviet bureaucracy is progressively identified with
opposition to socialism itself. The bureaucratic leadership is thereby
transformed from a historically specific political stratum into the
personification of socialism, and criticism of the bureaucracy becomes by
definition counter-revolutionary. This ideological formula had justified persecuting
the Left Opposition long before Basmanov wrote his book.
Consequently, this framework pushed aside the historical
questions that might have discredited it. What was the social basis of
bureaucratisation in the Soviet Union? Why did Lenin, in the final period of
his political life, express increasing alarm over the growth of bureaucratic
tendencies? What political meaning did the theory of socialism in one country
have, which had never formed part of the Bolshevik Party programme before 1924?
What explained the catastrophic policies pursued by the Communist International
in Britain, China and Germany? And why did the Soviet leadership undertake the
physical extermination of so large a section of the revolutionary generation
that had led the October Revolution?
These questions lead directly to writings that official
Soviet polemics could not answer through historical investigation alone:
Trotsky’s The Third International After Lenin, his writings on Germany and the
rise of fascism, and, above all, The Revolution Betrayed.
The fundamental political significance of The Revolution
Betrayed lay in Trotsky’s attempt to explain the Soviet Union's contradictions
from a Marxist standpoint. He rejected both the Stalinist identification of the
bureaucracy with socialism and the claim that the October Revolution had
created another form of capitalism. He instead characterised the Soviet Union
as a degenerated workers’ state in which the social gains represented by
nationalised property coexisted with a parasitic bureaucratic caste exercising
political power. Whether that analysis was correct is a historical and
political question requiring serious examination. Basmanov instead begins from
the legitimacy of the Soviet bureaucracy and evaluates its opponents
accordingly.
The shadow of the Moscow Trials
A deeper historical continuity is involved. Basmanov's 1972
language was less murderous than that of the Great Terror, but the basic
political logic had changed far less than the softer terminology suggested.
Trotskyism continued to be presented not as a Marxist tendency whose political
analysis might be right or wrong, but as a fundamentally anti-revolutionary
phenomenon serving forces hostile to socialism.
That accusation was central to the Stalinist campaign
against the Left Opposition. During the Moscow Trials of the 1930s, former
leaders of the Bolshevik Revolution were accused of extraordinary conspiracies
and subsequently executed. Trotsky, exiled from the Soviet Union, was made the
central political defendant in absentia.
The twentieth-century history of Stalinism therefore cannot
be separated from the history of anti-Trotskyism. Opposition to Trotsky was not
one ideological feature among many. It played an essential role in destroying
the political memory of the October Revolution and establishing a new official
version of Soviet history in which Stalin's emergence appeared as the
legitimate continuation of Bolshevism.
The contradiction became particularly striking after Nikita Khrushchev denounced parts of Stalin’s record. Once it was conceded that crimes on an enormous scale had been committed, an obvious question followed. What of the political opposition that had fought the bureaucracy before those crimes reached their height? Answering that question required reconsidering the history of the Left Opposition itself.
What Basmanov cannot explain
Basmanov’s book's decisive weakness follows from its
political purpose. To acknowledge Trotskyism as a genuine Marxist opposition to
bureaucratic domination would have required reopening the basic political
struggles through which the Stalinist regime consolidated itself. This problem
extends beyond Trotsky personally. The history of the Fourth International
after his assassination posed equally difficult questions for Soviet
apologetics.
Particularly important was the 1953 conflict within the
Fourth International associated with the tendency headed by Michel Pablo and
Ernest Mandel and the formation of the International Committee of the Fourth
International. The issue was not simply one more organisational split among
left-wing groups. At the centre of the conflict was a debate over the
historical role of Stalinism and other bureaucratic and nationalist formations.
For an official Soviet polemicist, treating all these
conflicting tendencies as undifferentiated “Trotskyism” was politically
convenient. The distinctions disappeared, and with them disappeared the awkward
fact that one of the central conflicts within postwar Trotskyism concerned
precisely whether revolutionary Marxists should adapt themselves politically to
the Stalinist bureaucracies and allied movements.
The homogenisation of politically hostile tendencies
therefore performs an ideological function. It lets Basmanov construct
“Trotskyism” as a single counter-revolutionary phenomenon rather than examine
the historical struggles through which different movements claiming the
Trotskyist inheritance evolved.
A surprisingly useful primary source
However, Basmanov’s work contains an irony that the
publisher of the new edition itself emphasises. Unlike many polemics in this
genre, Contemporary Trotskyism quotes extensively from the publications of the
movements it attacks. The publisher calls it unusually well documented for a
Soviet source on the post-1968 radical left, noting its references to
publications from several countries.
This gives the book a secondary value quite different from
the one its author intended. It can be read as evidence of what the Soviet
bureaucracy monitored, which tendencies it considered threatening, and how its
ideological institutions tried to categorise developments on the international
left.
The book is therefore potentially illuminating when approached against the grain. The reader should ask not merely, “What does Basmanov say about the Trotskyists?” but “Why was an institution of the CPSU commissioning and publishing this argument in 1972?” Seen in this way, the polemical excess becomes historical evidence.
History’s verdict
The greatest problem confronting Basmanov’s argument emerged
after he published his book. Trotsky insisted that bureaucratic rule did not
provide a stable path to socialism. His conception of political revolution stemmed
from the contradiction between the nationalised property relations produced by
the October Revolution and the bureaucracy's political domination. In his
analysis, defending the social foundations created by October required the
Soviet working class to remove the bureaucracy and restore workers’ democracy.
The ultimate fate of the Soviet Union therefore poses a
decisive historical question: which analysis more penetratingly captured Soviet
society's contradictions, the bureaucracy's apologetics or the Marxist
opposition to it? The state whose political invincibility was assumed
throughout official Soviet literature disappeared in 1991. The CPSU ceased to
rule. The Soviet Union was dissolved, and capitalist property relations were
restored across the former USSR.
This does not mean that every prediction made by every
tendency describing itself as Trotskyist was vindicated. Nor does the collapse
of the USSR automatically settle every controversy over Soviet history. But it
does require the central claims of official Soviet ideology to be subjected to
an accounting that Contemporary Trotskyism, for obvious chronological reasons,
could never make. The bureaucratic order Basmanov defended did not provide a
stable and irreversible transition to communism. Its political institutions
proved incapable of preventing capitalism's restoration.
This is why Soviet historian Vadim Rogovin's work matters in
any retrospective assessment of Basmanov. In his multi-volume Was There an
Alternative?, Rogovin reconstructed the history of the Left Opposition and the
struggle against Stalinism as a real political conflict rather than treating
the bureaucracy's ascendancy as the inevitable outcome of the Russian
Revolution. The very title posed the historical question that decades of
official Soviet historiography had sought to suppress: was Stalinism the
unavoidable development of Bolshevism, or did a Marxist alternative exist?
From this perspective, the conflict between Stalinism and
Trotskyism cannot be relegated to a dispute between personalities or rival
factions. It concerned the international strategy of the socialist revolution,
the relationship between Soviet economic development and world revolution, the
nature of socialist democracy and, ultimately, whether the bureaucratic regime
would defend or undermine the social foundations established in October 1917.
The new introduction
The 2026 edition's distinguishing feature is Dmitry
Chasovennikov's introduction. The available evidence here requires an important
correction to the assumption that the reissue straightforwardly represents an
attempt to revive Basmanov’s political standpoint. The publisher explicitly
describes the new introduction as “written from inside the tradition the book
sets out to bury” and presents Basmanov’s book as “Moscow’s book-length answer
to the post-1968 growth of the Fourth International”. Amazon reproduces
substantially the same description, characterising the original as a Soviet
attack on Trotsky, the Fourth International and the far left. [amazon.co.uk]
That substantially changes how the republication should be
evaluated. On the evidence available from the publisher, the book is being
presented not simply as a restored Stalinist polemic for contemporary use but
as a historically situated document accompanied by a critical introduction. Nevertheless,
one important question remains that the publisher’s promotional description
alone cannot settle: how far does Chasovennikov’s introduction pursue the
historical implications of the collapse of the Soviet Union, the archival
record of Stalinist repression, and the political disputes inside the Fourth
International? Without the complete text of the introduction, it would be
unjustified to attribute specific answers to him.
The responsible criticism, therefore, is not to pretend that
the new editor endorses Basmanov. The more interesting question is what
contemporary readers can learn from republishing the book as an historical
document.
Why republish it now?
On that basis, there is a legitimate reason to make
Contemporary Trotskyism available again. Stalinist anti-Trotskyism deserves
historical study. So do the institutions that manufactured it, the political
vocabulary they employed and the historical episodes they systematically
distorted or suppressed.
Indeed, the publisher’s framing unintentionally makes the
book particularly suitable for such a reading. It notes that Basmanov’s polemic
followed Ponomarev’s 1971 directive, stresses the political circumstances of
its appearance, and explicitly characterises the volume as a response to the
revival of revolutionary currents after the late 1960s.
Read critically, therefore, Contemporary Trotskyism can
illuminate a significant episode in the ideological history of the Cold War. It
shows how the Soviet bureaucracy understood the challenge revolutionary
movements posed to its left and how it sought to inoculate Communist Party
members and sympathisers against Trotsky’s political legacy. But precisely
because of this, the book should never be read in isolation.
Readers seeking to understand these controversies should
place Basmanov alongside the principal documents produced by the people he
attacks. They should read Trotsky on permanent revolution, the Communist
International, the German catastrophe, the Soviet bureaucracy and the founding
of the Fourth International. They should investigate the Moscow Trials and the
subsequent historical and documentary record. They should examine the conflicts
within the Fourth International rather than accepting an omnibus category
called “Trotskyism”.Above all, they should compare the rival historical
perspectives with what actually happened.
A museum piece, but an instructive one
The most striking feature of Contemporary Trotskyism today
is the disappearance of the political world from which it spoke with such
institutional confidence. Basmanov wrote from within an enormous state and
party apparatus that declared itself the authoritative embodiment of
Marxism-Leninism and treated Trotskyism as a defeated deviation relegated to
history. Yet the CPSU and the Soviet Union are themselves gone.
The political questions Trotsky fought over have not
disappeared with them. The relationship between nationalism and international
socialism, the political independence of the working class, the dangers of
bureaucracy, the character of revolutionary leadership and the relationship
between socialist revolution and democracy remain indispensable questions for
anyone attempting to understand the twentieth century or the crisis of
contemporary capitalism.
That is the final irony surrounding Basmanov’s resurrection.
His book sought to demonstrate that Trotskyism belonged to the past. Half a
century later, Basmanov’s polemic returns primarily as a historical artefact
from a vanished political apparatus.
The new edition can therefore perform a useful service,
provided it is read critically and historically. Approach contemporary
Trotskyism not as an authoritative guide to Trotsky or the Fourth
International, but as a primary source for understanding how the Soviet
bureaucracy represented its Marxist opponents in the last decades of its
existence.
And there is an appropriate way to test its claims. Read
Basmanov. Then read Trotsky. Read the Left Opposition documents and the
political conflicts within the Fourth International. Read the archival
scholarship produced after the dissolution of the Soviet Union. Finally, set
the conflicting analyses against the history that followed.
That historical comparison transforms this republished
polemic from an attack on Trotskyism into an unintended document of the
political order against which Trotskyism fought.
Bibliography
Primary text
Basmanov, Mikhail Ivanovich. Contemporary Trotskyism: Its
Anti-Revolutionary Nature. Moscow: Progress Publishers, 1972. The digitised
original identifies the Institute of Marxism-Leninism of the CC CPSU and
confirms the 1972 English printing. [archive.org]
Basmanov, Mikhail Ivanovich. Contemporary Trotskyism: With a
New Critical Introduction. Introduction by Chasovennikov. Progress Publishers
Library, 2026. The electronic edition is listed as appearing in September 2026.
[progresspu...ishers.org],
[fnac.com]
Basmanov, Mikhail. Where Are Trotskyites Leading the Youth?.
Moscow: Novosti Press Agency Publishing House, 1973. [openlibrary.org]
Trotsky and the Left Opposition
Trotsky, Leon. The Permanent Revolution. 1930.
Trotsky, Leon. The Third International After Lenin.
1928.
Trotsky, Leon. The Revolution Betrayed: What Is the
Soviet Union and Where Is It Going? 1936.
Trotsky, Leon. The Transitional Program for Socialist
Revolution. 1938.
Trotsky, Leon. In Defence of Marxism. 1942.
Stalinism and the historical struggle over Trotskyism
Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Armed: Trotsky, 1879–1921.
Oxford University Press, 1954.
Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Unarmed: Trotsky, 1921–1929.
Oxford University Press, 1959.
Deutscher, Isaac. The Prophet Outcast: Trotsky, 1929–1940.
Oxford University Press, 1963.
Rogovin, Vadim. Was There an Alternative?
Multi-volume study of the Left Opposition, Stalinism and the political
struggles in the Soviet Union.
North, David. The Heritage We Defend: A Contribution to
the History of the Fourth International. Detroit: Labour Publications,
1988.
Further reading
Broué, Pierre. Trotsky. Paris: Fayard, 1988.
Serge, Victor. From Lenin to Stalin. 1937.
Sedov, Leon. The Red Book on the Moscow Trials. 1936.
