That question could hardly be more urgent. The old
organisations that claimed for generations to represent the working class have undergone
a protracted collapse. The Labour Party has moved ever further from the
reformist programme it was historically identified with, while the trade-union
bureaucracy increasingly functions as an apparatus for containing workers’
struggles. The destruction of manufacturing employment, the privatisation of
state industries, the erosion of social provision and the growth of precarious
employment have transformed the social landscape in which millions live.
Gibbs brings considerable knowledge to this subject. He is a
Senior Lecturer in Economic and Social History at the University of Glasgow and
describes his research interests as encompassing energy, industry, work and
protest. His earlier book, Coal Country: The Meaning and Memory of
Deindustrialisation in Postwar Scotland, examined the decline of deep coal
mining in Scotland and its consequences for work, communities, memory, class
and nationhood. His subsequent research has extended into the political economy
of energy and the problems associated with industrial transition.
The empirical virtues of this work should not be dismissed.
Verso stresses the prominence Gibbs gives to first-hand accounts, while Rhian
E. Jones praises the book specifically for “letting its subjects speak for
themselves”. The recollections of miners, engineers and workers from
communities devastated by industrial closure constitute important historical evidence.
Such testimony preserves experiences that would otherwise be submerged beneath
official statistics and the complacent narratives of politicians who have
treated deindustrialisation as the unavoidable price of economic modernisation.
But the preservation of experience does not by itself
provide a historical explanation. History must establish the relationship
between experience and the social forces that produced it. It must explain not merely
what happened, but why, which political forces intervened, what programmes they
advanced, and what alternatives existed. It is precisely here that the concept
of the “unmaking” of the British working class raises fundamental problems.
From the “making” to the “unmaking” of the working class
The title consciously echoes E. P. Thompson’s The Making of
the English Working Class. The intellectual ancestry of the argument is made
especially clear by Gibbs’s 2019 essay, “The Unmaking of the British Working
Class: A Highly Provisional Thesis”. There he defined the “unmaking” primarily
through the atrophy of what he called “Labourism”: the political and
institutional world centred on organised labour and its attachment to the
Labour Party. He linked this process to deindustrialisation, suburbanisation,
the demise of collective action, and the political demoralisation visible in
former industrial areas.
This is an important starting point because the decline of “Labourism”
is not identical to the disappearance of the working class. The conflation of
the two contains the central theoretical difficulty. The working class is not
defined by living in a mining village, wearing overalls, possessing a
particular regional accent or belonging to a trade union. It is defined
fundamentally by its relationship to the means of production. Workers who do
not own significant productive property must sell their labour power to live.
Changes in technology, occupation and geography can profoundly alter the forms
through which class consciousness develops without abolishing the underlying
class relation.
Indeed, Verso's own description of An Injury to All
illustrates the contradiction. It describes a class once “forged in mines and
shipyards” becoming one spread across call centres and gig-economy
applications. But this is not, strictly speaking, the disappearance of the working
class. It is a transformation in the occupational structure and geographical
concentration of wage labour. What has been shattered is something different:
an historically specific form of working-class organisation and consciousness
that grew alongside nationally regulated capitalism and became politically
subordinated to the Labour and trade-union bureaucracy.
The distinction is decisive. If the decline of mining,
shipbuilding, steelmaking and large-scale manufacturing automatically meant the
decline of the working class, then the pessimistic conclusions associated with
post-industrial sociology might follow. But if capitalist restructuring
destroyed certain concentrations of workers while simultaneously producing new
ones, the historical problem changes entirely. We are no longer asking why the
working class disappeared. We are asking why organisations created in its name
proved incapable of responding progressively to this transformation.
The exhaustion of national reformism
The postwar settlement in Britain emerged from definite
international historical conditions. The Depression, fascism, and the Second
World War had radicalised workers' masses internationally. Britain emerged from
the war economically weakened and increasingly subordinate to the United
States. At the same time, the long postwar economic expansion provided the
resources to make significant social concessions while preserving capitalist
property relations.
Nationalisation, the National Health Service, expanded
welfare provision, council housing, and collective bargaining did not abolish
capitalism. They represented concessions made within it under the immense
pressure of the working class. This was the environment within which Labourism
acquired its postwar authority. The Labour Party claimed that Parliament could
gradually transform capitalism while trade unions negotiated improvements
within the existing economic order. The bureaucracy’s privileged position
depended on its ability to mediate between workers and employers.
The breakdown of the postwar economic order increasingly
undermined this arrangement's foundations. The growing internationalisation of
production brought national industries directly into competition within a
globally organised system of production and finance. British capitalism
responded by demanding wage restraint, rationalisation, closures, deregulation and
attacks upon social spending. The Labour and trade-union bureaucracy confronted
a historical choice. Either the working class had to challenge capitalist
property relations, or its organisations had to accept British capitalism's
demands. They chose the second course.
This is the history that the language of “unmaking”
threatens to obscure. Workers did not wake up one morning and decide that
solidarity had become unfashionable. Collective institutions did not simply evaporate
under the influence of individualism or suburbanisation. Nor was Thatcherism
merely the ideological expression of an inexplicable change in national
“structures of feeling”. A sustained political offensive targeted the working
class, and the organisations through which workers traditionally fought
increasingly became mechanisms for suppressing resistance. From the standpoint
of Marxism, therefore, Thatcherism cannot be understood independently of the
crisis of Labourism. The strength of the Conservative offensive ultimately
depended on the political paralysis its existing leadership imposed on the
working class.
The miners’ strike and the decisive historical defeat
The 1984-85 miners’ strike occupies an unavoidable position
in any account of this transformation. Verso foregrounds the miners’ struggle
in An Injury to All, describing its narrative as extending from the miners’
picket lines to contemporary Amazon warehouses. The strike represented a
historic confrontation between the working class and the Thatcher government.
The government understood that the miners represented far more than one
occupational group. Their defeat would alter class relations throughout Britain.
But the decisive question is therefore not simply why the
mines subsequently closed. It is why the miners were defeated. An explanation centred
upon geographical restructuring or the weakening of industrial solidarities
reverses cause and effect. The demoralisation that followed the destruction of
the coalfields cannot adequately explain a defeat that helped produce that
demoralisation.
Consequently, labour movement leadership becomes
indispensable. The miners needed to mobilise the working class as a whole.
Instead, their struggle remained confined to an industrial dispute, while the
Labour and trade-union bureaucracy opposed any political mobilisation that
could threaten the Thatcher government. The subsequent devastation of the
coalfields was enormous. Jobs disappeared, communities lost their economic
foundations, and decades of accumulated collective experience came under
sustained pressure. But these consequences must be understood historically as
the aftermath of a major political defeat.
Gibbs’s 2019 essay provides valuable evidence of the bitterness
that survived in former coalfield constituencies. Discussing Bolsover, he noted
hostile memories of the miners’ strike and how electoral allegiances
subsequently fractured. He placed this within a broader trajectory of
deindustrialisation, demobilisation, and declining attachment to the labour
movement. But hostility towards the
former institutions of the labour movement cannot be treated merely as evidence
of weakening working-class identity. It must also be understood as the
distorted product of decades of bitter political experience.
Workers repeatedly mobilised through organisations that
claimed to represent them, only to discover that those organisations refused to
wage a struggle against the social order responsible for declining living
standards and industrial destruction. The resulting alienation did not mean
class antagonism had disappeared. It showed Labourism's growing inability to contain
that antagonism within its traditional political forms.
Hobsbawm, Marxism Today and the retreat from the
working class
The theoretical lineage behind the concept of “unmaking”
therefore deserves closer examination. Eric Hobsbawm’s famous intervention,
“The Forward March of Labour Halted?”, offered an influential formulation of
the claim that the traditional working class was losing the social weight
socialist politics had supposedly depended on. Such arguments subsequently
became central to the Eurocommunist current associated with Marxism Today.
The consequences were far-reaching. Rather than examining
the betrayals the working class suffered and the need to build an alternative
revolutionary leadership, this tendency increasingly treated changes in
capitalism's occupational composition as evidence that class politics itself
had to be supplemented or replaced by broader democratic politics organised
around diverse social constituencies.
The political development eventually contributed to an intellectual
climate in which accommodation to the market could be presented as realism.
What had begun as an argument about changes within the working class became an
argument for abandoning the working class as the central revolutionary agency
of socialist politics.
It is significant in this respect that Gibbs opened his 2019
essay with Hall’s formulation from “Gramsci and Us”: “You lose because you lose
because you lose.” The phrase encapsulates the danger of converting political defeats
into sociological inevitabilities. Workers lose. Industrial communities
decline. Labour loyalties disintegrate. Nationalism or right-wing populism
fills the vacuum. History becomes an accumulation of defeats whose explanation
resides increasingly in transformed identities, cultures and geographies. But
Marxism must ask a different question: why did they lose?
Who led these struggles? What political programme did that
leadership defend? What alternatives were suppressed? Why did enormous demonstrations
of working-class militancy repeatedly terminate in retreats brokered by
organisations that claimed to represent the workers? Once those questions are
posed, the history of postwar Britain assumes a profoundly different shape.
The working class was transformed, not abolished.
The central empirical fact confronting the “unmaking” thesis
is that capitalism has not transcended wage labour. It has enormously extended
it. The old industrial landscape has certainly disappeared in many areas. The
pit head, shipyard and steelworks that once dominated entire towns have closed.
Millions no longer work in enterprises around which dense occupational cultures
developed over generations. But capitalism replaced them with other forms of
proletarian labour.
Hospitals, schools, logistics depots, supermarkets,
telecommunications networks, warehouses, call centres and digital platforms
depend upon vast numbers of wage workers. Privatisation has transferred former public
services into corporate hands while retaining workers whose labour remains
socially indispensable. The important historical transition, therefore, is not
from a working-class society to a post-working-class society. It is from one
configuration of the working class to another.
The social character of production has meanwhile become
vastly more international. A worker employed in a warehouse or logistics depot
in Britain participates in production and distribution systems that extend across
continents. Components, data, finance and commodities cross national borders
continuously. Capital already organises production internationally. Labour
remains politically divided by national institutions. This contradiction is
crucial because it suggests that nationally based Labourism cannot accommodate
it. The development of globalised production did not destroy the material basis
for international working-class solidarity. It strengthened it.
The turn towards nationalism
Here the Scottish dimension of Gibbs’s political outlook
becomes especially revealing. In his 2019 New Socialist essay, he argued that
Labour’s future in Scotland required breaking with its commitment to the
unitary British state. He described nationalism as having “displaced Labourism”
in Scotland, supported recognition of the right to another independence
referendum and advocated pressure upon the Scottish government to defy
Westminster. He suggested that such confrontation could be accompanied by civil
disobedience. An important democratic question concerns opposition to coercive
attempts to suppress national aspirations. But that does not settle
nationalism's class character or establish it as a progressive alternative to
Labourism. The Marxist starting point must be the independent interests of the
working class.
A worker in Glasgow does not have fundamentally antagonistic
social interests to a worker in Liverpool, Newcastle, Cardiff or London. They
confront the same capitalist ownership structures, financial institutions, and,
increasingly, the same multinational corporations. Nationalism translates capitalism-generated
social grievances into political demands organised around national territory.
It thereby offers another national programme precisely when capitalist
development has made economic life more internationally integrated than ever
before. The answer to the exhaustion of British national reformism therefore
cannot be Scottish national reformism.
Changing the constitutional boundaries within which
capitalist property relations operate does not abolish those relations. Neither
does exchanging administration from Westminster for administration from
Edinburgh resolve the contradictions between wage labour and capital. If the
decisive historical development since the 1970s has been the
internationalisation of capitalist production, the socialist response cannot
consist of creating smaller national frameworks within which workers continue
competing for investment. It must politically unify workers across national
boundaries against globally organised capital.
Grangemouth and the limits of “just transition”
Gibbs’s recent work on Grangemouth provides a contemporary expression
of these issues. His University of Glasgow profile describes his research into
energy and industrial transition and records his involvement in work on the
Grangemouth refinery closure. His publications include “Workers’ perspectives
on an unjust transition: place, history, and workplace closure at Grangemouth
oil refinery, Scotland”, “The Grangemouth oil refinery closure: lessons for
‘just transition’ governance” and, in 2026, “Scotland’s unjust transition: the
view from Grangemouth”. Grangemouth sharply frames the conflict between social
need and private ownership.
The fundamental question is not whether workers should be
consulted more effectively about industrial transition. It is who controls the
productive resources upon which entire communities depend. Workers possess
enormous accumulated technical knowledge. Yet under capitalist ownership, the
continued operation or closure of productive facilities ultimately depends on
profitability. Decisions affecting thousands of lives appear as the private
prerogative of corporations and investors. A genuinely rational transition to
sustainable energy production would begin from entirely different premises.
Society would determine energy investment according to environmental need and
human welfare rather than private profit. Workers displaced from environmentally
damaging production would be guaranteed decent employment, training and living
standards as productive resources were redirected. But such planning
immediately raises the property question. Who owns the energy industry? Who
controls investment? Who determines whether a refinery, power station or
industrial plant operates? Who decides what replaces it?
These are class questions rather than merely problems of
governance. A socialist programme would therefore fight to place major energy
corporations and strategic industries under public ownership and democratic
workers’ control as part of an internationally coordinated transformation of
production.
“Who speaks for labour?”
We can now return to the question Verso asks in An Injury to
All: “who now speaks for labour?” The wording itself can mislead. The
fundamental problem confronting workers is not discovering somebody willing to
“speak for” them. Labour politicians have spoken in workers' names for
generations. Trade-union officials do so every day. The real issue is political
leadership. A class becomes an independent political force only when it
understands its historical interests and develops organisations capable of
fighting for them. No amount of sociological reconstruction can substitute for
this task.
The old labour organisations developed within the
nation-state framework. Their bureaucracy mediated between working people and
national capital. When capitalist production became globally integrated, these
organisations did not become internationalist. Instead, they defended the
national economy more explicitly. The consequences followed inexorably. If
British companies had to become “competitive”, wages and conditions had to be
restrained. If investment might move elsewhere, workers had to accept
concessions. When factories faced closure, union leaders sought agreements to
persuade corporations that production would remain profitable.
The worker thereby ceased to be represented as a member of
an international class and instead became a cost on the balance sheet of “our”
national economy. This transformation cannot be understood merely as weakened
solidarity. It was the political bankruptcy of nationalism and reformism under
conditions of globally organised capitalism.
Not the unmaking of the working class, but the collapse
of Labourism
This is ultimately the conceptual problem contained in the
title An Injury to All. What disappeared was real and historically significant.
Mining communities were devastated. Manufacturing towns were hollowed out.
Trade-union membership declined. Labour loyalties weakened. Institutions
through which generations of workers had expressed a collective identity
deteriorated.
But none of this established that the working class ceased
to exist. What collapsed was the identification of working-class politics with
a particular set of national institutions. This distinction completely changes
the historical perspective. If the working class has been “unmade”, socialist
politics becomes an exercise in assembling coalitions among fragmented
identities, regions and social movements. Politics moves from class towards
culture, nationality and electoral sociology.
If Labourism has been exhausted while the working class itself
has been objectively enlarged and internationally integrated, an entirely
different conclusion follows. The problem becomes one of revolutionary
leadership. The central lesson of the last half century is not that workers
possessed too much belief in class struggle. Rather, enormous manifestations of
class struggle remained politically subordinated to organisations committed to
defending capitalism. The task therefore cannot be to recreate the labour
movement of the 1950s.
Nor should socialists romanticise the industrial communities
that have disappeared. Their solidarity and collective traditions represented
tremendous achievements, but national reformism, trade-union bureaucracy, and,
in important areas, Stalinism also dominated their political life. The future
cannot be built by reconstructing the past's institutional arrangements.
An injury to one is an injury to all.
Gibbs’s title is therefore ironic. “An injury to one is an
injury to all” contains a conception far more radical than nostalgia for industrial
Britain's vanished institutions. It expresses the elementary internationalist
truth that workers share fundamental interests arising from their common
relationship to capital. Today that proposition possesses an objective material
foundation on an unprecedented scale.
The worker in a British warehouse is integrated into the
same international production and distribution processes as workers throughout Europe,
Asia and North America. The nurse confronting deteriorating public services,
the teacher facing declining real incomes, the delivery worker controlled
through an application and the engineer employed by a multinational corporation
occupy different workplaces but confront the same fundamental relationship
between labour and capital.
Capitalism has globalised production while preserving
private ownership and the nation-state system. It has created the material foundations
for international working-class unity while continuously mobilising nationalism
to prevent that unity from assuming conscious political form. That
contradiction, rather than the disappearance of the proletariat, defines the
present historical period. Gibbs has accumulated valuable material concerning
the experience and memory of deindustrialisation. His previous work
demonstrates sustained engagement with the workers and communities most
immediately affected by industrial restructuring. His research encompasses
precisely the terrain upon which some of the central class conflicts of modern
Britain have unfolded. But An Injury to All cannot ultimately be resolved
through oral history, electoral sociology, or the politics of national reconstruction.
“Who speaks for labour?” is the wrong question if it means searching among the
remains of Labourism for another institutional representative. The working
class must speak for itself.
Doing so requires a political movement independent of the
Labour Party and the trade-union bureaucracy, hostile to every attempt to
divide workers by nationality, and consciously based on the international
character of modern capitalist production. The British working class was not
“unmade”. A historically specific labour movement based upon national reformism
has undergone a profound degeneration and collapse. The distinction is not
semantic. It determines whether the defeats of the past half century are seen
as evidence of the disappearance of working-class politics or as historical
experiences from which a new socialist movement must draw lessons.
The mines closed. Shipyards disappeared. Council estates were sold. The institutions associated with Labourism decayed. But labour did not disappear. Capital could not survive for a single day without it. The historical question is therefore not how to reconstruct the Britain of the postwar settlement. It is how the enormously expanded and internationally interconnected working class can transform itself from an objective social force into a conscious political force. In that sense the old slogan remains entirely contemporary: an injury to one is an injury to all. But taking those words seriously means following them beyond Labourism and nationalism to their necessary political conclusion: the international unity of the working class in the struggle for socialism.
Bibliography
Gibbs, Ewan. An Injury to All: The Unmaking of the
British Working Class. London: Verso, 2026. [versobooks.com]
Gibbs, Ewan. Coal Country: The Meaning and Memory of
Deindustrialisation in Postwar Scotland. London: University of London
Press, 2021. [gla.ac.uk]
Gibbs, Ewan. “The Unmaking of the British Working Class: A
Highly Provisional Thesis.” New Socialist, 19 December 2019. [newsocialist.org.uk]
Hobsbawm, Eric. “The Forward March of Labour Halted?” Marxism
Today, September 1978.
Hall, Stuart. “Gramsci and Us.” Marxism Today, June
1987. Gibbs uses Hall’s “You lose because you lose because you lose” as the
epigraph to his 2019 essay. [newsocialist.org.uk]
Nairn, Tom. The Break-Up of Britain: Crisis and
Neo-Nationalism. London: New Left Books, 1977.
Shibe, Riyoko and Ewan Gibbs. “The Grangemouth oil refinery
closure: lessons for ‘just transition’ governance.” Journal of the British
Academy, 13 (1), 2025. [gla.ac.uk]
Marsden, Chris and Julie Hyland. “Britain: 20 years since the
year-long miners’ strike.” World Socialist Web Site, 5 March 2004. This is
particularly relevant to your argument because it links the miners’ defeat to
the roles of Labour and the TUC and connects the exhaustion of national
reformism to the globalisation of production. [wsws.org], [wsws.org]
Marsden, Chris and Julie Hyland. “Forty years since the British
miners’ strike.” World Socialist Web Site, 5 March 2024. The article places the
1984-85 struggle within the international shift toward deregulation, global
investment, and internationalised production, and argues that the reformist and
Stalinist organisations' betrayals were decisive in this period's defeats. [wsws.org]
