Kazuo Ishiguro’s original novel presents a genuinely
disturbing world. Children from affluent families can be genetically “lifted”,
providing advantages unavailable to others. Artificial Friends are manufactured
as commodities, purchased as companions and ultimately discarded. Adults have
undergone “substitution”, a euphemism for technological displacement. Beneath
the quiet domestic surface lies a society increasingly divided between
privileged layers able to purchase the benefits of scientific progress and a
population whose labour is no longer required by those who own and control the
productive forces.
Ishiguro’s achievement should not simply be dismissed. He is
intensely sensitive to human vulnerability and to the fear of abandonment,
ageing, loneliness and loss. Klara’s observations of the people around her
expose the insecurity underlying apparently comfortable lives. The story asks
serious questions about what constitutes humanity and whether technology can
replicate affection, loyalty, memory, and personality. But this sensitivity is
inseparable from a profound resignation before existing society.
The same limitation was already apparent in Never Let Me
Go. A society raises cloned human beings so that their organs can
eventually be harvested, yet the victims offer virtually no collective
resistance to the system responsible for their fate. The extraordinary
passivity is clearly deliberate, but it also reveals the boundaries of
Ishiguro’s social vision. His characters suffer history rather than make it.
Social relations produced through historical development consequently acquire
the appearance of permanent existential conditions. Alienation becomes loneliness,
inequality becomes personal misfortune, and social oppression becomes a
condition to be endured rather than transformed.
This is one of the characteristic intellectual problems
confronting contemporary culture. Many writers and artists are genuinely
disturbed by inequality, technological disruption, environmental catastrophe,
authoritarianism, and war, yet see no social force capable of fundamentally
reorganising society. Capitalism therefore disappears as a historically
specific system at precisely the point when its consequences dominate the
artistic imagination.
Klara and the Sun therefore raise the decisive questions it
cannot adequately answer. Who owns the Artificial Friends? Who controls the
technology responsible for “lifting”? Why should a scientific development
capable of increasing human capacities become a privilege available primarily
to prosperous families? What happens to those workers who have been
“substituted”? Above all, why should increasing productivity produce
unemployment, insecurity and social disintegration rather than greater leisure,
prosperity and cultural development?
These questions change Klara's significance. Under different
social relations, automation and artificial intelligence could progressively
liberate humanity from dangerous, exhausting and monotonous labour. Artificial
intelligence could drive major advances in medicine, scientific research,
education, engineering, and artistic production. Rising productivity could make
a radical shortening of the working week possible and an enormous expansion of
time available for education, cultural activity, and human development.
Under capitalism, however, technological development
confronts the worker antagonistically because the productive forces remain
privately owned. Corporations do not primarily introduce labour-saving
technology to liberate human beings from unnecessary labour. They introduce it
because technological innovation can reduce labour costs, increase
productivity, and strengthen profitability. The extraordinary potential of
artificial intelligence therefore collides directly with the social relations
in which it is developed.
Consequently, Klara is deeply unsettling as a figure. She is
obedient, endlessly patient and entirely devoted to those who purchase her. She
demands no wages, possesses no independent economic interests, never organises,
never strikes and ultimately accepts her own dispensability. She resembles, in
exaggerated form, the ideal employee contemporary capitalism imagines:
intelligent, adaptable, and endlessly productive, but with no demands of her
own.
The idealisation of Klara’s self-sacrifice therefore
contains implications that the story never seriously confronts. She becomes
morally admirable partly because she desires virtually nothing for herself.
What appears as a touching meditation on loyalty and selflessness can
consequently be read as something far more disturbing. Klara is the worker who
asks for nothing and can ultimately be put aside when her usefulness has ended.
The fundamental question raised by artificial intelligence
is therefore not whether machines will eventually acquire souls, emotions or
consciousness. Nor is it primarily whether artificial intelligence can imitate
human creativity convincingly enough to replace a novelist, actor, illustrator
or musician. The decisive social question is who owns this technology, who
determines its purposes, and which social class benefits from the enormous
increases in productivity that technological development makes possible.
It would therefore be a serious mistake to identify
technological development itself as the source of unemployment. A machine does
not demand the dismissal of the worker. An algorithm does not require
dividends. Artificial intelligence has no inherent social requirement to
impoverish the population whose accumulated intellectual and physical labour
ultimately made its creation possible. Those consequences arise from the
capitalist organisation of production.
In a rationally organised society, increasing productivity
would mean progressively reducing the labour required of every individual while
raising living standards. Under capitalism, the same development confronts
workers as redundancy, wage pressure and insecurity. The contradiction lies not
between humanity and technology but between the increasingly social character
of production and the private ownership of the productive forces.
This is precisely the historical dimension largely absent
from Klara and the Sun. The weakness cannot be overcome merely by adding
more explicit political dialogue to the story or putting revolutionary
declarations in Klara’s mouth. The deeper problem concerns the conception of
society underlying the work. A culture that experiences capitalism as
effectively permanent will inevitably present its contradictions as existential
tragedies. Unemployment becomes displacement, inequality becomes loneliness,
technological development becomes destiny and political reaction becomes an
unexplained eruption of irrational behaviour.
What disappears is the working class as a conscious
historical force. This absence has enormous artistic consequences. Without an
understanding of social contradiction in its living historical form, conflict
retreats increasingly into individual psychology. Characters remember, grieve,
endure and reconcile themselves to circumstances that appear beyond human
control. Society may be profoundly diseased, but nothing emerges from within
that society capable of overcoming the conditions producing the disease.
That is why the resignation embodied in Klara and the Sun
matters. Its world is technologically extraordinary but politically paralysed.
Humanity has developed machines capable of reproducing increasingly complex
intellectual functions, altered biological capacities, and eliminating enormous
quantities of necessary labour. Yet, society remains trapped in inequality,
competition, and private ownership. The contradiction between the productive
forces and existing social relations could hardly be more sharply posed.
The alternative is therefore not less technology but
different social relations. Artificial intelligence, robotics, and automation
must stop functioning primarily as instruments through which a small corporate
and financial oligarchy enriches itself at the population's expense. Instead,
the immense productive capacities accumulated through generations of collective
human labour must be placed under social ownership and democratic control.
Under such conditions, “substitution” would acquire an
entirely different meaning. Automation would no longer mean workers become
disposable because their labour no longer produces sufficient profit. Instead,
it could mean shortening the working day, eliminating degrading labour, and
making the benefits of technological progress universally available. What
capitalism experiences as the terrifying possibility of human beings becoming
unnecessary to production could become an unprecedented expansion of human
freedom.
This is the future that Klara and the Sun struggles
to imagine. Ishiguro senses something profoundly wrong with contemporary
society but experiences its contradictions predominantly as moral and
psychological conditions. The result is a work characteristic of an important
tendency within contemporary culture: technologically fascinated, socially
anxious, genuinely humane in certain respects, but ultimately resigned before
the existing order.
Great art does not require artists to append political
programmes to their work. Balzac and Tolstoy were not great because they
possessed politically correct opinions, nor can Brecht’s importance be reduced
to the slogans associated with his politics. What distinguished the greatest
artists was their capacity, however contradictory their personal outlooks, to look
beneath social appearances and reveal something about society's movement itself.
That is the challenge confronting serious artistic
production in the age of artificial intelligence. The tragedy is not that
humanity has developed machines capable of replacing increasing quantities of
human labour. The tragedy is that humanity’s accumulated technological
achievements remain subordinated to social relations that transform abundance
into insecurity, rising productivity into unemployment and potentially
liberating technologies into instruments of exploitation.
The question Klara and the Sun pose is therefore far greater than whether Klara herself is human. It is whether humanity will continue to let private profit dictate technological development or consciously reorganise economic life so these remarkable productive powers serve society as a whole. Klara’s unquestioning self-sacrifice offers no solution to that contradiction. The working class does.
Selected bibliography: Ishiguro
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. A Pale View of Hills. London: Faber & Faber, 1982. [mostrecomm...dbooks.com], [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. An Artist of the Floating World. London: Faber & Faber, 1986. [mostrecomm...dbooks.com], [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. The Remains of the Day. London: Faber & Faber, 1989. [mostrecomm...dbooks.com], [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. The Unconsoled. London: Faber & Faber, 1995. [mostrecomm...dbooks.com], [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. When We Were Orphans. London: Faber & Faber, 2000. [mostrecomm...dbooks.com], [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. Never Let Me Go. London: Faber & Faber, 2005. [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. Nocturnes: Five Stories of Music and Nightfall. London: Faber & Faber, 2009. [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. The Buried Giant. London: Faber & Faber, 2015. [editorsreads.com]
- Ishiguro, Kazuo. Klara and the Sun. London: Faber & Faber
Beams, Nick. “AI development and the contradictions of capitalism.” World Socialist Web Site, 14 February 2026. A particularly useful Marxist treatment of AI as a productive force whose possibilities come into conflict with capitalist private ownership and the profit system. [wsws.org]
Hall, Tom. “How workers can fight the wave of AI layoffs.” World Socialist Web Site, 10 May 2026. Examines corporate deployment of AI in connection with layoffs and argues that the central issue is social control of the new technologies. [wsws.org]
Reed, Kevin. “Artificial intelligence and the film and television writers’ strike.” World Socialist Web Site, 10 May 2023. Especially relevant to the review because it documents the conflict over AI during the Writers Guild of America strike, including the WGA's demands concerning AI-written material and the training of AI systems on writers' work. [wsws.org]
_poster.jpg)