“ A Low, Dishonest Decade”.
1939 English poet WH Auden
Brian Reade’s comparison of the 2026 World Cup to Hitler’s
1936 Olympics has triggered the usual hand-wringing in liberal circles. Despite
its rhetorical flair, Reade’s argument—like all moralistic complaints from the
declining Labour-aligned press—falls apart due to political evasions. The
comparison with 1936 is not incorrect; what is flawed is the conclusion he
draws from it.[1]
The United States, hosting the 2026 World Cup, is not just
"controversial"; it embodies global imperialism through its illegal
war against Iran, supporting the Gaza genocide, and conducting mass arrests and
deportations of immigrant workers, unprecedented in recent American history. As
has been reported, ICE agents will be present at every stadium. The Iranian
team has been denied visas and faced what can only be seen as a veiled death
threat from Trump. Meanwhile, the Congolese team has been targeted with a
racist quarantine order that reflects the imperial disdain typical of the
US-NATO war efforts.
Comparing these events to 1936 is more than an exaggeration;
it's an understatement. The Nazi regime used the Berlin Olympics to project an
image of a peaceful, cultured Germany while secretly preparing for genocide.
Likewise, the Trump administration exploits the World Cup to spread a message
of “unity,” even as ICE functions as an anti-immigrant force similar to the
Gestapo, and the Pentagon conducts widespread destruction in the Middle East.
Yet, beyond these parallels, the comparison quickly falls apart—and it exposes
the political shortcomings of Reade’s framework.
The Liberal Myth of 1936
Reade, like all liberal moralists, references 1936 as a
moral story: Jesse Owens humbling Hitler, representing individual bravery
overcoming bigotry, and suggesting that sport can “shame” authoritarian
regimes. This narrative serves as the mythology of a ruling class eager to hide
its own complicity.
The stark truth is that by 1936, the German working class
was crushed. The Communist Party and Social Democrats had betrayed the
proletariat, paving the way for Hitler’s rise. Western democracies, especially
Britain and the United States, did not boycott Berlin; instead, they
collaborated. The American Olympic Committee, led by fascist-sympathizer Avery
Brundage, fiercely resisted any boycott efforts. Meanwhile, US companies like
IBM and Ford gained significant profits through their association with the Nazi
regime.
The lesson from 1936 is not that sport can be corrupted by
bad governments, but that the capitalist elites worldwide will cooperate with
fascism when it benefits their interests. Only the unified effort of the global
working class could have prevented Hitler’s rise, and only such collective
action can now prevent our slide into war and dictatorship.
The Liberal Illusion of Boycotts and Moral Appeals
Reade’s strategies—such as boycotts, moral condemnations,
and appeals to FIFA or the “international community”—are typical of a political
tendency that has detached itself from the working class. These approaches rely
on the false belief that the capitalist state and its institutions can be
coerced into ethical actions.
However, FIFA is not an impartial judge corrupted by Trump;
rather, it functions as a tool of global capitalism. Its president, Gianni
Infantino, awarded Trump the bizarre “FIFA Peace Prize.” The tournament’s
design—opening match in Mexico City with the later rounds held in the United
States—reflects the geography of imperial power.
What about the governments Reade suggests might “take a
stand”? Starmer’s Labour largely supports US imperialist wars as a loyal junior
partner. The Democratic Party managed the same deportation system and
imperialist machinery before Trump came back into office. Appealing to these
forces means aligning with those responsible for the disaster.
Sport as a Weapon of the Capitalist State
Reade’s framework embraces the nationalist idea that the key
issue in modern sport is determining which nation is “fit” to host. However,
every capitalist country employs sport as a means of nationalist mobilization.
The 2012 London Olympics, the 2014 Sochi Games, and the 2018 World Cup in
Russia—each was used to cloak social inequality and imperial ambitions with
patriotic symbolism.
However, the nationalist story is beginning to weaken.
During the Milan Winter Olympics, thousands demonstrated against Trump and ICE,
booing Vice President Vance. US athletes openly expressed their disapproval of
the regime. Freestyle skier Chris Lillis said he was “heartbroken” over ICE’s
actions and emphasized that athletes represent a different America than the one
involved in mass repression.
Even in the United States, the nationalist event is
faltering. While 75% of Americans are aware that the US is hosting the World
Cup, almost a third intend to support a different country. This significant
statistic highlights the immigrant heritage and globalist sentiments of
millions—sentiments that the ruling elite cannot eliminate.
The Working Class and the Real Lesson of 2026
Modern football was built by the working class, shaping its
culture, passion, and worldwide popularity— all rooted in working-class life.
Instead of a moral boycott by liberal columnists, the solution to the
nationalist spectacle of the 2026 World Cup is promoting awareness among the
political class. The 1936 Olympics happened after the German working class was
politically defeated and betrayed by Stalinism and social democracy. Similarly,
the 2026 World Cup unfolds at a time when the international working class has
yet to develop the revolutionary leadership needed to stop the progression
toward war and dictatorship.
The lesson is not that sport should be considered 'pure” or
“apolitical.” Throughout history, sport has always had political implications.
The real lesson is that combating fascism, war, and authoritarianism cannot be
delegated to FIFA, bourgeois governments, or the conscience of the ruling
class. Instead, it must be done by the international working class.
[1] Trump's World Cup is like Hitler's Olympics -
we have a major lesson to learn' www.mirror.co.uk/news/brian-reade-trumps-world-cup-37285848
